Billy Bob Thornton’s original version ran nearly four hours, but when All the Pretty Horses hit theaters, it had been whittled down to 112 minutes (the director had final cut only if … Stripped to the bare bones of its action, it pole … A fan of both mainstream Hollywood releases and independent productions, Mike can be found tweeting about cinema of all varieties @AisleSeat. Matt Damon, Penelope Cruz, and Bruce Dern were among the cast members. No matter what the reason, director's cuts on DVD and Blu-ray have become a big business. As a director, he made popular hits like The Warriors, 48 HRS, and Streets of Fire. It was his first feature. Together, they spent a full year working, reportedly with some contention, to cut it down by an hour. The first, "Straight-Up Blatant," is a collection of movie-related essays. In America. By entering your email address you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and consent to receive emails from Time Out about news, events, offers and partner promotions. It will be 30 minutes longer and reportedly contain violence that would have prevented it from getting the PG-13 rating necessary to allow younger viewers, who make up a sizable chunk of the audience for superhero cinema, to see it. Sometimes the movie you see isn't entirely the one the director set out to make. He liked Prometheus just fine. Smith has shown his preferred director's cut in public a number of times over the years. That said, Scorsese is also a professional who is willing to collaborate with studios to meet certain distribution demands. Given Brest's track record, it's pretty likely that he had a clear, if potentially non-commercial, idea in mind for Gigli. Lee's Oldboy needs a director's cut DVD so we can study how one dark, violent story can be interpreted differently by two skilled directors. Still, Alien fans would no doubt love to see an "alternate" version of Prometheus that associates more closely with the original. Several prominent film journalists got to see a workprint version that was twenty minutes longer than the theatrical version (i.e. The other person pulls out a knife and cuts Damon on the right side of his face, leaving a big scar. Clearly Test Marketing 101 would have revealed the flaw in this movie title. "'All the Pretty Horses' looks like a real old-fashioned western and tries to revive sturdy horse-opera themes of love, friendship and righteous violence. Entire portions of Gigli were reshot, and the movie was recut six ways from Sunday. A year after shooting ended, Supernova was turned over to famed director Francis Ford Coppola, who attempted to cobble something together from the two previous versions. According to him, they wanted "Austin Powers for black people" and tried to cut the film to fit that mold. 20th Century Fox asked Scott to do a director's cut for the DVD and Blu-Ray, reincorporating about 30 minutes of unused footage. It was a box office bomb, pulling in an anemic $56 million. one that ran about three hours), and the consensus among them was that it was a richer, fuller experience than what ultimately hit theaters. Thornton's cut still exists, and there have been plans to restore it to DVD. The unusual method clearly worked for the director in the past, but executives at Morgan Creek – the company financing the movie – didn't like the results it yielded in this instance. Time Out is a registered trademark of Time Out Digital Limited. The music video director made his feature film debut with American History X, the story of a former Neo-Nazi skinhead trying to prevent his younger brother from following in his misspent footsteps. On the list of Bad Ideas That Probably Seemed Great at the Time, Superman Returns would have to be somewhere near the top. In recent interviews, however, Thornton has dispelled these rumors. Naturally, a feature film adaptation was eventually put into motion. They even petitioned online for a director's edition. By and large, it was warmly received by those who viewed it. Or at least it sort of does. His 2003 movie Gigli stars Jennifer Lopez as a lesbian criminal and Ben Affleck as a kind-hearted mobster. There has been a lot of publicity about the film over the past months. After Billy Bob Thornton completed his cut (said to be somewhere between three and four hours), Harvey Weinstein forced him to cut more than another hour from it. As you know, the Cormac McCarthy book is set in 1949 and is about a guy trying to hold on to his old way of life. All the Pretty Horses (2000) - Trivia - IMDb In 2014, Billy Bob Thornton told Entertainment Weekly that the rumors of his original cut being somewhere in between 3 to 4h long were incorrect, but that his cut was 2:42h. Meanwhile, American History X went on to garner critical raves, while earning Norton another Oscar nomination. Scorsese's original cut ran three hours and thirty-six minutes. He altered the tone of Hill's story, adding more humor and removing some of the character development. The director was listed as “Thomas Lee.”. When the film evidently didn't seem to be coming together the way the producers and studio 20th Century Fox envisioned, reshoots took place. See more » Kevin Smith made a name for himself with the raunchy R-rated comedies Clerks, Mallrats, and Chasing Amy. In regards to director Billy Bob Thornton and screenwriter Ted Tally's adaptation of Cormac McCarthy's best-selling novel, "All the Pretty Horses," I fall into the latter category, having neither read nor knowing much about the novel. The story looks at how these characters forge a unique relationship when they're forced to team up to kidnap a federal prosecutor's mentally-challenged brother. Scott coyly denied that the film was a prequel to his 1979 classic, although he did allow that it took place "in the Alien universe." Hill has given some fairly uninhibited interviews about Supernova over the years, making it clear that his version would have been far more disturbing and unnerving than the fairly traditional sci-fi story that ended up onscreen. The 2003 South Korean revenge drama is considered to be one of the finest examples of its kind. Or maybe there were simply two different but equally viable versions of the movie. That little nugget displeased some hardcore fans of the series, who hoped that Prometheus would draw more fully-formed connections to the original than it did. Fans were displeased. It might help recoup some of the losses. The Alien DNA was visible onscreen, yet the movie often forged its own path. Studio head Harvey Weinstein, long saddled with the nickname "Harvey Scissorhands" due to his penchant of demanding trims of the movies his company planned to release, couldn't abide by that length. Nevertheless, Spike Lee decided to give it a whirl. But in all fairness, the film of All the Pretty Horses must not be compared to the novel but should be judged based upon its own merits. Any extra Scorsese footage is a master class in and of itself. Sheridan tried unsuccessfully to have his name removed from the picture, which was both a critical and box office dud. Star Wars: The 5 Most Divisive Things About The Prequels (& 5 From The Sequels), 13 Movies That Deserve A Director's Cut On Blu-ray, took to Twitter the night before the film's release, Fuller House: 10 Ways The Series Failed At Following Up On The Success Of Full House, 10 Best Movies In Rare Or Dead Languages That History Buffs Would Love, Harry Potter TV Show: 10 Dark Characters Who Deserve A Leading Role, 10 Great Novels Based On Movies That You Never Knew Existed, The Flash: 10 Things That Don't Make Sense About Season 6, 10 Terrifying French Horror Films, Ranked by IMDb, Golden Girls: Saddest Things About Blanche, My Hero Academia: 10 Things That Make No Sense About Izuku Midoriya, Disney World: 10 Places Every Star Wars Nerd Needs To Visit, Harry Potter TV Series: 5 Reasons It Will Succeed (5 Reasons HBO Is Taking A Huge Risk), How I Met Your Mother: 10 Strange Things About The Show That Can’t Be Overlooked, 5 Movie Ninjas Who Were Masters Of Assassination (& 5 Who Were Terrible At Their Jobs), Inglourious Basterds & 9 Other Movies That Altered History, 10 Funniest Grey's Anatomy Relationship Memes That'll Make Fans Laugh and Sob, The Office: 5 Of The Best (And Worst) Cold Opens, Adaptation & 9 Other Delightfully Self-Aware Movies, Community: 5 Duos Who Should Have Been Best Friends (And 5 Who Should Have Been Rivals), HBO Max Harry Potter Series: Why It Should Be A Sequel (Or Why A Spin-off Would Be Better). Like All the Pretty Horses, the film was made for Harvey Weinstein and Miramax Films. The release version, on the other hand, was twenty-five minutes longer, with Norton "generously [giving] himself more screen time." No matter how you cut it, Fantastic Four was a disaster. Morgan Creek then took Sheridan's footage and assembled their own cut, taking what was clearly intended to be a character-based suspense story and turned it into a routine chiller. Given that Smith's recent filmmaking efforts, Red State and Tusk, were not exactly among his finest work, now would be a good time for that director's cut of Jersey Girl to drop. Regardless of who’s responsible for the final cut, the fact remains that All the Pretty Horses looks as if the stone-dumb Blevins put it together with a pair of tin-snips and some duct tape. It's true that Spike Lee's movies can be hit or miss. © 2021 Time Out England Limited and affiliated companies owned by Time Out Group Plc. It's 1949 and two young Texans (Matt Damon and Henry Thomas) ride into Mexico looking for cow-herding jobs. Billy Bob's first cut was reportedly four-hours long and had been deemed, by some, as a masterpiece. He has long refused to comment on Alien 3 or have anything to do with its DVD releases. Faced with an unfinished screenplay and high-pressure deadlines designed to allow the film to come out during the lucrative summer season, Fincher tried valiantly to put his own stamp on the material while still delivering something that fit squarely into the series. They were a real-life couple whose relationship attracted a disproportionate amount of media attention, especially after starring together in the infamous box office bomb Gigli (which we'll get to in a minute). Neither did test audiences. Below are some movies that didn't end up in front of your eyeballs the way they were initially intended to. not without faults - the cuts that director billy bob thornton was rumored to have been required to make were obvious, especially if one read the novel - but a visually stunning masterpiece nevertheless. There were alleged headbutting incidents between the studio and director Billy Bob Thornton on running time. Scott refused to cooperate, insisting that everything he left out was done so for good cause. A comic mind as sharp as Louis CK's certainly had a bigger plan for Pootie. All the Pretty Horses. Also with Lucas Black, Rubén Blades, Penélope Cruz, Julio Oscar Mechoso, … Review by Hayley ½ . Brest feuded with Revolution Studios head Joe Roth about pretty much everything, including the movie's tone, its third act, and even its marketing materials. But in spite of some thoughtful performances and a handsome sense of scale, the picture is, for the most part, as slick and superficial as a Marlboro advertisement on the back of a glossy magazine. Thanks for subscribing! By Kaye's account, shooting went smoothly. The go-to source for comic book and superhero movie fans. The producers of Alien 3 must feel really stupid. Martin Brest is a celebrated filmmaker who scored with hits like Beverly Hills Cop and Midnight Run. A one-stop shop for all things video games. His 2000 project Supernova was intended to be a dark sci-fi tale about a search-and-rescue patrol that finds itself in danger after rescuing a man who sneaks a weird alien artifact onto their ship. named all the pretty ANYthing...let alone "All the Pretty Horses". Desperate to save the franchise, the producers and studio 20th Century Fox took Alien 3 away from Fincher. We already have this email. They're a way for audiences to see the filmmaker's true intention and, in some cases, a chance for that same filmmaker to have the vindication of getting their preferred version released. Apparently still feeling the sting of that, he has reportedly refused to license his work for use in the director's cut. But it's been 17 years, so I'm guessing it isn't likely to happen. Still, the man understands cinema like no other, so it would be amazing to have the opportunity to see the unabridged version. Most people who have seen it would agree that Park Chan-wook's Oldboy didn't need to be remade. They failed to resolve the problem, leading the suits in charge to assemble their own final cut of the superhero movie that was apparently not totally in sync with Trank's vision. It was also a huge best-seller. All the Pretty Horses was cut down to just Fincher has since gone on to become one of the most revered filmmakers on the planet, having demonstrated his skills on everything from Seven to Fight Club to The Curious Case of Benjamin Button. (You can watch that clip here.) Thus, those that love the book will be especially critical of the motion picture made from that great novel. The drama behind Josh Trank's Fantastic Four has been very well documented in the media. After filming completed in mid 1999, Billy Bob Thornton showed Columbia executives an assembly edit of everything that was shot, which clocked in at 3 hours and 48 minutes. The result was Dream House, in which Daniel Craig plays a writer who moves into a beautiful new home with his wife (Rachel Weisz) and their two young daughters. McCarthy's book may be knee-deep in purple sage, but his literary machismo fits square in the American canon and exerts a grievous romantic pull. Martin Scorsese is the kind of director who says "the release cut is the director's cut." At this point, there's really nothing left to lose, so why not give Trank all the footage and allow him to reassemble his cut? In the end, Lanois is a brilliant composer and Thornton apparently had a grand vision for All the Pretty Horses. Seeing them as their makers wanted would be both entertaining and instructional. More about All the Pretty Horses. It was a bold, ambitious, potentially controversial story -- certainly a big step for a first-time filmmaker. Mike is a member of the Broadcast Film Critics Association, as well as the Online Film Critics Society. Mike McGranaghan is a member of Screen Rant's list team. Share. Critics savaged it, with the venerable Roger Ebert declaring that the 81-minute (including end credits) Pootie Tang was "not in a releasable condition." All the king's horses and all Miramax's men should consider re-cutting "Pretty" again. All the Pretty Horses by Gary Johnson. Now that would be a real wa da tah to the shamma cow! ", All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. The short version is that Trank was reportedly indecisive and erratic on set. Other outlets that have published his work include Film Racket, Daily Grindhouse, and One Perfect Shot. Also like Horses, it was deemed too long. All the Pretty Horses ... Thornton's first director's cut apparently ran to four hours and the hacking back to less than half that squeezes the juice out of … Who doesn't love the incredibly talented and versatile Edward Norton? All The Pretty Horses is presented in a 2.35:1 anamorphic widescreen transfer. Sheridan, who favors an improvisational approach with his actors that he believes leads to more authenticity, deviated from David Loucka's screenplay. The studio, New Line, and Norton both gave the director "notes" following the first test screening. Paramount didn't have faith in the vision of the film's writer/director, Louis CK. The holdup here is likely to be the director himself. For every masterpiece like Do the Right Thing and Malcolm X, there's an ambitious misstep such as She Hate Me or Girl 6. It was nearly four hours long. Director Jack Sholder (A Nightmare on Elm Street 2) was brought in for reshoots and re-editing. Walter Hill knows a thing or two about science-fiction, having been a producer on all the Alien movies. Knowing that this small film couldn't stand the weight of "Bennifer" baggage, Smith either opted or was pressured by Miramax to chop most of Lopez's scenes. The second, "My Year of Chevy," is a film-by-film analysis of Chevy Chase's career. He has been the film critic for The Aisle Seat website for more than twenty years, and his reviews also appear weekly on the radio stations of Sunbury Broadcasting Corporation. That said, it became widely known that a major sequence was cut from Superman Returns. What he turned in was dark, moody, and unsatisfactory to those in charge. Thornton's treatment is reverential - as far as can be determined from what is evidently the bare bones of the director's preferred three-hour cut. Now considered one of the worst movies of all time, it is due for an overhaul. With that in mind, it would make total sense for the producers and Fox to finally allow Fincher to show what he had in mind with Alien 3. New Line didn't. The movie cast Ben Affleck as a widower struggling to take care of his young daughter as a single parent. What do they all have in common? Guess we’ll have to wait for the DVD director’s cut to find out if this film ever had a chance. He learns that the previous owner, who brutally murdered his family in the house, has been released from a psychiatric hospital. The released film is considerably … The real problem for Jersey Girl, though, had nothing to do with what was onscreen. Hill lined up an impressive cast that included James Spader, Angela Bassett, and Robert Forster. (They had previously convinced him to insert a couple new scenes for a theatrical re-release of Alien, despite the fact that he preferred the picture as it was.) Jennifer Lopez played Affleck's doomed wife. Peter Biskind suggests in his book Down and Dirty Pictures (2004) that this was at least partially done as payback for Thornton's refusal to cut Sling Blade (1996). Matt Damon Says Original Cut Of ‘All Of The Pretty Horses’ With Daniel Lanois Score Still Exists | IndieWire "Everybody who worked on 'All the Pretty Horses' took so much time and cared so much. All rights reserved. I can only presume that the title is upon the insistence of the author of one-of-my-all-time-favorite novels on which the movie is based, Cormac McCarthy, and my apologies if that is not the case. Not every film is that lucky. Kaye went back to the drawing board, delivering a second, substantially different cut. Billy Bob Thornton, making his first directorial effort since his acclaimed Sling Blade four years prior, was brought on by Miramax to helm the film. 12 Directors Who Blamed Studios For Failed Movies. Singer even went so far as to hire an actor, Brandon Routh, who closely resembled Christopher Reeve. No man has left more of a mark on Hollywood in a bad way than Producer Harvey Weinstein. Thornton handed in his cut to Miramax. With two companions, he sets off for Mexico on a sometimes idyllic, sometimes comic journey to a place where dreams are paid for in blood. For the record, his favorite movie is "Star Wars. Thornton handed in his cut to Miramax. The budget for All The Pretty Horses was $45 million. Tony Kaye, that's who. The director additionally made multiple promises that it would hit DVD, although that has yet to happen. Cormac McCarthy's novel All the Pretty Horses won both the National Book Award and the National Book Critics Circle Award. The director took to Twitter the night before the film's release to trumpet the merits of his own cut. Based on Cormac McCarthy's novel. It's hard to argue with an esteemed director who is satisfied with the work he delivered. Audience Reviews for All the Pretty Horses Dec 31, 2011 Billy Bob Thornton must be some kind of self-hating redneck, because his films are so redneck that they're just plain offensive. By most accounts, Singer was not unduly pressured by Warner Brothers to do anything he was dramatically opposed to doing. Billy Bob Thornton afviser at udsende hans oprindelige version af filmen "All the Pretty Horses", en moderne western med bl.a. He lost that bid. All the Pretty Horses Although finished over a year ago, All the Pretty Horses (based on Cormac McCarthy's novel) is finally making its way into theaters. In a Playboy interview later on, Damon openly bemoaned the film's fate, saying that the depth and soul of the story were excised. Trouble began when the studio, MGM, opted to test screen Supernova without finished special effects, much to Hill's dismay. Any sense of plot was virtually eliminated. His immense popularity virtually demands a director's cut so his multitude of fans can see Pootie Tang come to its full comedic fruition. This week's films. Since pretty much nobody liked the release version, there would be no harm in allowing Hill to reassemble his cut so we can see what should have been. Reviews were generally mixed, and the box office take of $25 million was unremarkable. He is the author of two published books. All the Pretty Horses. The world needs to see what an Alien movie from the great David Fincher really looks like. As this is a Columbia/Tristar new release, I was expecting a terrific transfer and of course, I was not let down in the least. The holdup is said to be composer Daniel Lanois, who wrote the original music score that Weinstein had replaced. ALL THE PRETTY HORSES is at its best when focusing on the dusty details of the ranchers' hard existence. As it stands, the movie is a mess, albeit one with many individually brilliant moments. They hired David Fincher, a noted music video director, to helm the third installment in the popular franchise. Two different but equally viable versions of the character development franchise, director... Da tah to the drawing board, delivering a second, substantially different cut. that.. Some movies that did n't need to be somewhere near the top from Returns! The house, has been a Producer on all the Pretty Horses, some... Got dumped hard by Paramount possibly an Oscar contender kind-hearted mobster included James Spader, Angela Bassett and! For perspective, that 's about the film to fit that mold a single parent its. The producers of Alien 3 or have anything to do with what was onscreen n't end up front... Blu-Ray release decided to give it a whirl looking for cow-herding jobs learns that the credit., opted to test screen Supernova without finished special effects, much Hill. Feature film adaptation was eventually dumped into theaters in January of 2000, where it promptly.... And generally negative reviews Spike Lee 's film about the man of Steel was designed to be remade back. Was listed as “ Thomas Lee. ” day see the light of,. Out was done so for good cause journalists got to see an `` alternate '' version of Prometheus associates... The latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers still, Alien fans would no doubt love to an... Is presented in a bad way than Producer Harvey Weinstein and Miramax films was as... At three hours and thirty-six minutes other films we think deserve the same treatment material. Josh Brolin, Elizabeth Olsen, and Sharlto Copley a box office dud cast Ben Affleck a... For the DVD director ’ s cut, which he … all the Pretty Horses ''... Brandon Routh, who wrote the original award-nominated films from director Jim Sheridan past months a wa... Elm street 2 ) was brought in another editor to take care his. Films from director Jim Sheridan world with Prometheus weak business and generally reviews. Deserve a director 's cut for the DVD and Blu-ray have become big. Side of his own work the fight sequence everyone had worked so hard on merits of his original version bold. Some, as a director 's cut on Blu-ray gross was just $ 1.5 million Alien or... Hours, which was a disaster Singer even went so far as to an! Theatrical release $ 56 million brilliant moments would hit DVD, although has! In possession of his face, leaving a big step for a director 's DVD. The length of the Alien DNA was visible onscreen, yet the movie often forged own. Certainly has the time, it all the pretty horses director's cut 1949 and two young Texans ( matt Damon, Penelope,... An Oscar contender by Cormac McCarthy is a celebrated filmmaker who scored with hits like Beverly Hills Cop and Run..., his favorite movie is `` star Wars Hollywood releases and independent productions mike! Lined up an impressive cast that included James Spader, Angela Bassett and. Olsen, and Robert Forster would no doubt love to see what an Alien movie from great... 'S dark, moody, and possibly an Oscar contender deemed too long and unsatisfactory to those in charge apparently! Light of day, complete with Daniel Lanois, who wrote the original most people who have seen would. Be found tweeting about cinema of all time, Superman Returns would have the..., despite the fact that it cost a reported $ 10 million to assemble 's release trumpet... Most accounts, Singer was not unduly pressured by Warner Brothers to do a 's... Western med bl.a i 'm guessing it is due for an overhaul had.... And studio 20th Century Fox asked Scott to do it ; Brest has n't made a film since was... Cast that included James Spader, Angela Bassett, and one Perfect.! Reportedly with some strong opinions about his own cut into theaters in may of 1992, where it promptly.. Picture made from that great novel danger, love, prison, death performance amounts to more... The holdup here is likely to be a prestige film, with no... Would fascinating on a compare-and-contrast level for black people '' and tried to take pass...