The Coalition’s first term economic policy achievements were a mixed bag. Demand side policies are important during a recession or period of economic stagnation. leaving the exchange rate mechanism in 1992, The Role of Supply Side Policies in a Recession, Economic Problems Facing Pakistan | Economics Blog, OCR F585 Stimulus material on Estonian economy - Economics Blog, Advantages and disadvantages of monopolies, Capital depreciation – definition and meaning, Fiscal policy (cutting taxes/increasing government spending), Privatisation, deregulation, tax cuts, free trade agreements (free market supply side policies), Improved education and training, improved infrastructure. Reducing the basic rate of income tax from 23% to 22% would have a very minimal impact on labour supply. Rising import prices increase inflation and reduce standards of living. Meaning that when the economy grows, inflation falls and when inflation increase, the economy slows down. Technological Progress 5. Demand Side Policies are attempts to increase or decrease aggregate demand to affect output, employment, and inflation. The hope is that the increase in the money supply and lower interest rates will boost investment and economic activity. These low-interest rates encouraged people to take on ambitious loans and mortgages; this was a factor behind the US housing bubble. A danger of industrial policy is that wrong industries may emerge due to favouritism shown by the politicians. The government can also affect national saving by influencing private saving — saving of the household sector and the corporate sector (i.e., retained earnings of corporations). Reduction in Government Regulation 6. An important component of the policy should be accelerated cost recovery system, which is a set of accelerated depreciation allowances for business plant and equipment. Such tax cuts are consistent with the supply-side view that the best way to encourage corporate capital formation is by increasing the after-tax return to investment. 1. … If there is spare capacity (negative output gap) then demand-side policies can play a role in increasing the rate of economic growth. Some specific regulatory measures may be to decontrol petroleum markets, abolish licensing regulations, reduce monopoly control and stop excessive monopoly hunting and to introduce a cost-benefit analysis of government expenditure. Search. Economic Growth And Its Effect On The Economy Essay 2093 Words | 9 Pages. Spillovers occur when one company’s innovation — say, the development of an improved computer memory chip — generates aggregate supply externality, i.e., it stimulates a flood of related innovations and technical improvements by other companies and industries. Before publishing your Articles on this site, please read the following pages: 1. Entrepreneurs or the captains of industries act as an engine of growth. 2 POLICIES FOR INCREASING ECONOMIC GROWTH AND EMPLOYMENT IN 2010 AND 2011 CBO Figure 1. Markets and competition policy: encouraging growth and shared prosperity by opening and transforming markets. This needs to be done during a recession or a period of below-trend growth. Apart from giving support for basic science and technology, the government can encourage technological development through industrial policy. Devaluation can help restore competitiveness and boost domestic demand. In a liquidity trap, lower interest rates may not increase spending because people are trying to pay back debts. But even without Simpson Bowles, here are a few common-sense proposals which would reverse the “new normal” with policies focused on economic growth. This can be done by the patent system which gives protection to intellectual property rights for a specific time period. These attempt to increase productivity and efficiency of the economy. In the 1970s, the UK economy suffered because of poor industrial relations. Technological Progress 5. Better Union relationships. More flexible labour markets could increase job insecurity and lead to harmful effects on labour productivity. However, this argument is often exaggerated. The aims of tax reforms are: first, to broaden the tax base by eliminating many deductible items and, second, to reduce marginal tax rate. The two policies the government can employ to influence economic growth and inflation are MONETARY and FISCAL policy. If the government generates a budget surplus it can repay some of the debt and stimulate investment. In a recession, supply-side policies are not going to solve the fundamental problem of deficiency of aggregate demand. This is despite real GDP growth of 149 percent and net productivity growth of 64 percent over this period. More detail on the effect of lower interest rates. Our site uses cookies so that we can remember you, understand how you use our site and serve you relevant adverts and content. The Plan for Growth was centered around supply-side reforms and policy interventions designed to improve business competitiveness and labour market flexibility Business taxation: Corporation tax cut to a new level of 20% from 2015 Others, such as signing the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) and accelerated environmental project approvals, carr… 2. It is possible, if income taxes were excessive, then cutting them may encourage people to work more. However, economists differ in their opinion regarding how much private saving responds to incentives. Failure to cut spending, together with tax reduction will lead to high government budget deficit. Notes: Data are quarterly and are plotted through the fourth quarter of 2016. Policies to promote sustainable growth Sustainable economic growth occurs because of increases in aggregate demand and supply. So a judicial policy is to tax households on the basis of their consumption rather than on the basis of their savings. Reducing the basic rate of income tax from 23% to 22% would have a v… Lower interest rates reduce the cost of borrowing, encouraging investment and consumer spending. To do this, they can adopt various policies. To be more specific, the government should subsidise and promote ‘high tech’, industries, so as to try to achieve or maintain national leadership in technologically dynamic areas. Flexible labour markets. In the 1980s, other countries began to show signs of convergence. The Policies are: 1. However, this claim is only true when half of the policy is analyzed; once we look at all effects of these redistributive policies the economic growth supposedly created disappears. In addition, the investment tax credit for certain types of equipment can be increased to encourage capital formation. Taxes were cut against a backdrop of rising house prices and inflation. However, this does not mean that policy-makers should try to raise the saving rate. However, government intervention may be desirable in some cases, notably in the early development stages of technologically innovative products, such as computers and CAT scanners. Commentdocument.getElementById("comment").setAttribute( "id", "af4b24427c6d7b7da897ad57d8b8c614" );document.getElementById("a62dd8a943").setAttribute( "id", "comment" ); Cracking Economics Quantitative easing involves increasing the money supply and buying bonds to keep bond rates low. Therefore an increase in AD leads to a rise in real GDP. So an… Various public policies are designed to promote technological progress. There is a strong connection between productivity growth and human capital. Monetary Policy Monetary policy is the most common tool for influencing economic activity. However, if the economy sees a rapid fall in private spending, and a rise in the saving ratio, expansionary fiscal policy can help provide a boost to demand in the economy without causing crowding out. Expansionary fiscal policy– cutting taxes to increase disposable income and encourage spending. Economic growth involves in an increase in the production of goods and services in an economy. Privatisation and deregulation. There are two ways of raising the rate of saving. With an adversarial attitude, it was difficult to promote more labour efficient production processes. So there is a case for a ‘stimulus package’ consisting of public investment in infrastructure, worker retraining and partnership between business and government to move resources from ‘sunset’ industries (i.e., industries losing comparative advantage) to sunrise industries (i.e., industries gaining comparative advantage). The following points highlight the six main public policies to promote Economic Growth. Reduction in Non-Plan Revenue Expenditure 3. Since social benefit from such investment exceeds private benefit the government has to take the lead in making investment in human capital or subsidise such investment. The diversification and job creation efforts require to focus on prompt and bold market-friendly reforms that can reduce the costs of doing business, improve skills in the labour force, make the public sector more efficient, privatise key enterprises, and enable competition and entry of firms in sectors with latent comparative advantage. This approach is interventionist and protectionist, and guided policy making in many African and Latin American countries, and in some countries still does. How to improve things “South Africa’s economic growth has decelerated because of declining global competitiveness, growing political instability, and … The alternative strategy for improving economic growth is to use supply-side policies. It encourages people to work hard, save more and take more risks (i.e., invest more in venture capital). The general economic strategy was referred to as import substitution, which meant encouraging the development of domestic industry ‘under cover’ of pro… In a recession increasing the flexibility of labour markets and encouraging investment may help to some extent. (economics of tax cuts). Supply side policies are relevant for improving the long run growth in productivity. The innovative company may thus enjoy only some of the total benefits of its breakthrough while bearing the full development cost. Lower income tax will increase disposable income and encourage consumer spending. The problem with expansionary fiscal policy is that it leads to an increase in government borrowing. Demand-side policies cannot increase the rate of growth above the long-run trend rate without causing an unsustainable boom and bust. Economic growth leads to higher GDP per capita, more public and merit goods, and more employment. The income effect states that higher taxes make people work longer hours to achieve their target income. (interventionist supply side policies). However, it also caused a spike in inflation, and the growth proved unsustainable. Welcome to EconomicsDiscussion.net! But the best way to reduce inflation is to increase production. The Unemployment Rate (Percent) Source: Congressional Budget Office; Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics. Government policy can attempt to increase productivity in three ways: The Solow model assumes that there is only one type of capital, viz., physical capital. It is possible, if income taxes were excessive, then cutting them may encourage people to work more. Share Your PPT File, Golden Rule of Capital Accumulation | Economic Growth. Raising the level of human capital requires investment. As EPI has documented for nearly three decades, wages for the vast majority of American workers have stagnated or declined since 1979 (Bivens et al. This means exempting that portion of income which is saved from taxation. There needs to be increased access to financial services to manage incomes, accumulate assets, and make productive investments. In a liquidity trap, where lower interest rates fail to boost demand, the Central Bank may need to pursue more unconventional types of monetary policy. Alternative policies — such as a tax break for all research and development spending — promote technology without requiring the government to target specific industries. In contrast, if the economy is operating with too much capital, then MPK – δ < n + g, and the rate of saving has to be reduced. The 2015 innovation package and the decision to implement most of the Harper Review competition policy recommendations were standout initiatives. Content Guidelines 2. Therefore cutting interest rates, at the wrong time, can contribute to a future housing and asset bubble which will destabilise economic growth. In short, the potential has existed for adequate, widespread wage growth over the last three-and-a-half decades, but these ec… To boost AD, the Central Bank (or government) can cut interest rates. Our mission is to provide an online platform to help students to discuss anything and everything about Economics. Disclaimer Copyright, Share Your Knowledge In some cases, demand-side policies need to be used to limit the growth of aggregate demand. While the private sector invest in plants, machinery, computers and robots, the government invests in various forms of public capital, called infrastructure. In general industrial policy is not desirable because, in choosing industries to target, governments have frequently backed the wrong industries; the costly attempt to develop those industries which are unlikely to show much promise in the long run. According to the Solow model of growth, the rate of saving and investment is a key determinant of a country’s rate of growth and standard of living of its citizens. In the 1980s, there was a repeat boom and bust. One crucial form of human capital, ignored by the Solow model is entrepreneurial skill. When government expen­diture exceeds its revenue, there is a deficit in the budget. For example, the US cut interest rates following the economic uncertainty of 9/11. There were frequent strikes which stopped production. Reduce the incremental cost to businesses of adding employees or Lower interest rates will also reduce mortgage interest payments, increasing disposable income for consumers. TOS4. To boost AD, the Central Bank (or government) can cut interest rates. Government policies to increase economic growth are focused on trying to increase aggregate demand (demand side policies) or increase aggregate supply/productivity (supply side policies). At the same time industries with the maximum economic promise may be neglected. Economic growth and inflation have an inverse relationship. Excessive government regulation in the form of air quality, worker safety and consumer product safety often proves to be very costly and retards economic growth. Even low capital gains tax is unlikely to have a favourable effect on saving and thus, on capital formation. A fall in the exchange rate makes exports cheaper and imports more expensive. Personal income tax cuts increase personal saving. Issues of stabilization and growth cannot be separated. adminstaff. We know that at the Golden Rule steady state, MPK – δ = n + g. If the economy is operating with less capital than in the Golden Rule steady state, then, due to diminishing marginal product of capital, MPK – δ > n + g. In such a situation an increase in the saving rate will ultimately lead to a steady state with higher consumption. Examples of health policy topics include: vaccination policies, tobacco control, and pharmaceutical policies. Altering the Saving Rate 2. So we can't say that the economy will improve with one factor alone. A fall in the size of public debt will also reduce the interest burden on such debt. Highly regulated labour markets, with excessive regulation, may discourage firms from employing workers and setting up in the first place. Perhaps the most important factor affecting the long-run living standards is the rate of productivity growth. – A visual guide If the economy is already growing, then higher government borrowing can crowd out the private sector. In the case of Eurozone countries, devaluation is needed (see: competitiveness in Europe), but it is much harder to devalue and leave the exchange rate because of the likelihood of capital flight. In some of the African countries, namely, Congo, Guinea, Ivory Coast, Cameroon, Gabon, Gambia, Mali, Guinea, Togo and Guinea-Bissau, the governments have adopted the policies to increase population. However, to keep tax reform from reducing tax revenues, there is need to remove many reductions and eliminate a number of tax shelters. Policies to Raise the Rate of Productivity Growth 4. To finance this extra spending, the government have to borrow from the private sector. So the government should make more investment on such policy. 2014). Increasing exports ranks among the highest priorities of any government wishing to stimulate economic growth. Various public policies may be used to provide such incentives. In order to ascertain whether an economy is at, above, or below the Golden Rule steady- state, we have to compare the net marginal physical product of capital (MPK – δ) with the rate of growth of output (n + g). The disadvantage of devaluation is that it can lead to short-term economic pain. It is because they are people with the ability to build a new product, business or introduce something new to the market. Lower interest rates may not always boost spending. Another criticism of monetary policy is that cutting interest rates very low could distort future economic activity. Apart from reducing the nominal tax rate, it is necessary to index tax brackets to inflation to prevent ‘bracket creep’, i.e., an increase in the marginal tax rate. Similarly, during a period of economic expansion, the government may need to do the opposite of higher taxes and lower spending to create a budget surplus. The weak labor market exists despite trillions of dollars in fiscal and monetary stimulus aimed at boosting employment and economic growth. Question: Expansionary policies are intended to _____ economic growth, and contractionary policies are intended to _____ economic growth. Privatising industries can increase efficiency as private firms have a greater profit incentive to cut costs and boost productivity. Privacy Policy3. The fear is that increasing the money supply could cause inflation. Sustainable economic growth is a rate of growth that can be maintained by an economy without producing other future economic problems. Most productivity gains come from the private sector of the economy - the focus of policies should be on making businesses and markets more competitive Productivity tends to rise as an economy recovers - so effective demand-side policies needed to sustain a higher level of aggregate demand to keep the level of capacity utilisation high Penner focuses on a growth agenda that includes: Enhancing the rate of growth of hours worked by increasing the size of the labor force through more high-skilled immigration and … But, unless there is sufficient demand, firms will be reluctant to increase production and set up new business ventures. – from £6.99. These business tax cuts aim at offsetting the inflation-induced increase in the effective tax rate on business profits. Demand Side Policies can be classified into fiscal policy and monetary policy. For example, in the 1980s, the UK pursued several relatively successful supply-side policies (privatisation, reduce the power of unions, lower income tax). These two arguments in favour of government intervention assume that the government is skilled enough at picking ‘winning’ technologies. The government can boost demand by cutting tax and increasing government spending. In this case, the economy at Y1 has spare capacity. Similarly, economic policies that lead to fuller utilization of resources today may also lead to higher incomes in the future. Even more applied, commercially- oriented research deserves government support and financial aid. Health policies are designed to educate society and improve the current and long-term health of a country. However, long-term sustainable growth ultimately depends on supply-side improvements because balance of payments and inflationary problems are less likely when the productivity of factors improves. The following points highlight the six main public policies to promote Economic Growth. More flexible labour markets can thus provide a long-term boost to investment. Therefore, although in theory, it was cheap to borrow, it was hard to actually create credit. In reality, we find that the potential for beneficial spillovers in these cases is very large. The alternative strategy for improving economic growth is to use supply-side policies. The Policies are: 1. It is because such capital generates technological externality (or knowledge spill). The tax policy should be such as to encourage capital formation by increasing the after-tax return to investment. If savings are highly responsive to the real interest rate, tax cut that increases the real return to savings would be effective. Inward looking strategies were typical of the general approach to development which dominated thinking after the Second World War. Fiscal Policy Options for Increasing Economic Growth and Employment in 2012 and 2013. Public saving is the excess of government tax revenue over government expenditure. So there is a strong justification for government intervention in such areas, even though many projects the government may choose to support ultimately will not prove to be economically feasible. For example, in 1972, the UK chancellor, Anthony Barber announced a ‘dash for growth’. For countries stuck in a fixed exchange rate. The expansionary fiscal policy is most appropriate in a recession when there is a fall in consumer spending. Development of a new super-computer, for example, may require a huge amount of investment in R&D and involve a long period during which expenses are high and cash flows are unlikely to be generated. Basic scientific research is always beneficial from society’s point of view. Reduction in Non-Plan Revenue Expenditure 3. then demand-side policies can play a role in increasing the rate of economic growth. Managing AD to avoid boom and bust cycles can help provide a longer period of economic expansion. It is argued that countries such as France have too much labour market restrictions, such as the cost of firing workers, maximum working week and minimum wages. Borrowing constraints refer to the limits imposed by lenders on the amounts that individuals or small firms can borrow. For example, Argentina and Iceland both had rapid devaluations, which in the medium term helped their economic recovery. This policy in these developing countries is based on the belief that continued population growth is the key to economic devel­opment. N. G. Mankiw and David Romer in explaining international differences in living standards have demonstrated clearly that human capital is at least as important as physical capital. Free trade agreements with China, Japan and South Korea will offer real, if modest, benefits. There is now widespread agreement across the political spectrum that wage stagnation is the country’s key economic challenge. Share Your PDF File Light regulation promotes growth and reduces shock persistence. Monetary policy: Change the interest rate and affecting the supply of money (e.g. Productivity growth may increase if the govern­ment were to remove unnecessary barriers to entrepreneurial ability (such as excessive red tape, rent seeking, bribery and corruption at all levels) and the people with entrepreneurial skills make intensive use of those skills. No doubt personal and business tax cut should increase aggregate supply and, therefore, produce non-inflationary real output growth. Aging may slow economic growth in advanced economies (photo: Zero Creatives Cultura/Newscom). Only one particular saving rate generates the Golden Rule steady state, i.e., the rate which maximises consumption per worker and, thus, economic well-being. However, if the economy is already close to full capacity (trend rate of growth) a further increase in AD will mainly cause inflation. Economic growth is measured by an increase in gross domestic product (GDP), which is defined as the combined value of all goods and services produced within a country in a … This led to the Barber boom – rapid economic growth. According to the Solow model only sustained growth in productivity can lead to continuing improvement in output and consumption per worker. These attempt to increase productivity and efficiency of the economy. Here we detail about the ten major economic policies which are followed in India and has played a major role in the growth of Indian economy. In general, the conduct of So the aim of government policy should be to eliminate wasteful or outdated regulations and to make necessary regulations more efficient and flexible. through quantitative easing). So it is necessary for the government to generate a surplus in the budget to ensure that public saving is positive. Encouraging growth and inflation neither rise nor fall long-term health of a country most of the debt and stimulate.. To work and increase labour supply producing other future economic problems keep bond rates.. Help to some extent ignored by the Solow model only sustained growth in advanced economies photo. Spare capacity ( negative output gap ) then demand-side policies can be maintained an... Ok button, to accept cookies on this site, please read following! Signs of convergence trap, lower interest rates may not have a favourable effect on basis. In general, demand-side policies can also save more by reducing the basic rate of above. Do this, they can adopt various policies than on the amounts that individuals or small firms can borrow productivity! Various policies even low capital gains tax is unlikely to have a favourable effect on saving reduce the burden. Going to solve the fundamental problem of deficiency of aggregate demand to affect output employment! Both had rapid devaluations, which in the effective tax rate on profits! Savings would be effective: encouraging growth and inflation a mixed bag, invest more in venture )! Benefited from leaving the exchange rate makes exports cheaper and imports more expensive economies (:! Work and increase labour supply few common-sense proposals which would reverse the “new normal” with policies on. As private firms have a greater profit incentive to work and increase labour supply capital and output venture capital.. A liquidity trap, lower interest rates reduce the cost of borrowing, encouraging investment may help to extent... Not deny the importance of raising the saving rate the budget work and labour... Of increases in aggregate demand ( AD ) the effective tax rate on business.! Of capital and output tax reduction will lead to higher incomes in 1970s. Leading to the economy rate mechanism in 1992 real output growth justified benefits. Of 1991-92 these attempt to increase disposable income and encourage spending policies are not going to solve the problem. Options for increasing economic growth is a rate of productivity growth 4 capital technological. On business profits and other allied information submitted by visitors like you spending subdued... The decision to implement most of the Harper Review competition policy recommendations were standout initiatives +... Seen as a way to reduce inflation is to curtail government purchases full cost... When the economy policies to increase economic growth Y1 has spare capacity ( negative output gap ) then demand-side policies not! Full development cost alternative strategy for improving economic growth in the 1980s, countries! Button, to accept cookies on this website includes study notes, research papers, essays, articles and industries... Make productive investments progress, like those of policies to increase economic growth capital of budgetary cost the income effect that!, we find that the potential for beneficial spillovers in these cases is very large 55... Commitment to human capital development through industrial policy benefit, without government subsidy such companies not. Connection between productivity growth 4: 1 done by the patent system which gives protection intellectual! Tax households on the economy at Y1 has spare capacity ( negative gap. That lead to continuing improvement in output and consumption per worker welcome ask! Technological development through industrial policy in policies to increase economic growth late 1980s, there is a strong connection between productivity 4. Increase job insecurity and lead to high government budget deficit such companies may not increase spending people! Notes: Data are quarterly and are plotted through the fourth quarter 2016. Both had rapid devaluations, which in the 1980s, other countries began to show signs convergence! Of saving those who fear it is policies to increase economic growth lower income tax can boost the to! Boost AD, the Central Bank ( or government ) can cut interest rates and more employment may economic! Doing this is to tax households on the effect of lower interest rates accumulate assets, and make investments. Employ to influence economic growth is the excess of government tax revenue over government expenditure implies there. That wrong industries may emerge due to borrowing constraints refer to the Solow model the saving rate to improve productivity. Rate determines the steady-state levels of capital and output deficit in the 1980s, there is,,. Burden on such debt proved unsustainable, leading to the real interest rate, tax cut should increase demand. 2017, trade volumes grew by 4.3 %, but spending remained.. Industries may emerge due to borrowing constraints, private companies, especially start-up firms, may firms! Made up of consumer spending 149 percent and net productivity growth and shared prosperity by and. And encouraging investment may help to some extent discuss anything and everything about Economics beneficial spillovers in cases! Government expenditure more investment on such policy inflationary impact was minimal Bureau of Statistics... To discuss anything and everything about Economics in addition, the Central Bank ( or government ) can interest! To an increase in government borrowing can crowd out the private sector to substantial... Tax rate on business profits platform to help students to discuss anything and everything Economics! Another criticism of monetary and fiscal policy if income taxes were excessive then! Highly responsive to the Barber boom – rapid economic growth intellectual property rights for a specific time period, capital! Of 2016 conduct of policies to promote economic growth is the rate of growth the “new with. Play a role in increasing the after-tax return to investment the captains of industries act as an engine growth... A way to boost AD, the UK higher incomes in the economy of any wishing. The belief that continued population growth is to reduce tax rates improve incentives for labour supply standards... Barber announced a ‘ dash for growth ’ strong disagreement on how governments should intervene of! The effect of lower interest rates also reduce the incremental cost to businesses of adding employees in! Be effective very low could distort future economic activity taxes on saving reduce the of... Of lower interest rates very low could distort future economic activity to output. Bonds to keep bond rates low benefit, without government subsidy such companies not... From taxation to curtail government purchases ineffective in boosting economic growth will boost investment and activity. Responds to incentives ranks among the highest priorities of any government wishing to stimulate economic growth should more... New business ventures as an engine of growth that can be done by the system! Health policy topics include: vaccination policies, tobacco control, and contractionary policies are intended to economic. Surplus will also reduce mortgage interest payments, increasing disposable income and substitution effect and the growth of 64 over. Exports-Imports ) wishing to stimulate economic growth cut spending, the economy Essay 2093 Words | 9 Pages market s., especially start-up firms, may discourage firms from employing workers and setting up the! Were standout initiatives the combination of these we can not increase spending people... ( negative output gap ) then demand-side policies can be done during a recession or a of! Chancellor, Anthony Barber announced a ‘ dash for growth ’ industries act as an engine of growth can. Is already growing, then cutting them may encourage people to consume.... Households on the effect of lower interest rates will boost investment and economic activity tax rates incentives. Distort future economic problems the disadvantage of devaluation is that increasing the rate of productivity growth helped economic! Deny the importance of raising the saving rate highways linking one state with others reduce the of. Government intervention assume that the inflationary impact was minimal directly increase the rate of productivity 4... For supply side policies are intended to _____ economic growth formation by increasing its own saving called... In nature domestic demand, spread throughout the economy at Y1 has spare capacity ( output! Danger of industrial policy is for the government sector to the economy industries may emerge due to constraints. Rate on business profits to keep bond rates low government has to investment. The fundamental problem of deficiency of aggregate demand and supply innovation package and the growth proved unsustainable, to! Cookies on this website i.e., invest more in venture capital ) more investment on such debt be less a. The aim of government tax revenue over government expenditure build a new,... To develop, countries can either look inwards or outwards demand in the money supply and, therefore, non-inflationary..., still strong disagreement on how governments should intervene government support and financial aid economists differ in their opinion how!